The Narrow Track Dana 30 |
Post Reply | Page <12 |
Author | ||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
The inner shafts are the larger 30 spline shafts. The outer shafts are still 27 spline.
https://www.rcvperformance.com/ultimate-dana-30-cv-axle-set-for-jeep-cj-72-81narrow-track-30-spline.html http://www.pirate4x4.com/forum/axles-tires-wheels-sale/1226218-dana-30-jeep-cj-narrow-track-30-spline-superior-evo-front-chromoly-axleshafts.html It is a common upgrade. |
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
oldtime
Member Joined: 12 Sep. 2009 Location: Missouri Status: Offline Points: 4140 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Oh O. K. then that would be lsimilar to one of Herms full floating rear D44 kits.
In that case I would certainly expect the 27 spline stub shafts will be the weakest part.
|
||
Currently building my final F-134 powered 3B .
T98-A Rock Crawler using exclusive factory parts and Approved Special Equipment from the Willys Motors era (1953-1963) Zero aftermarket parts |
||
Metcalf
Member Sponsor Member Joined: 21 May 2009 Location: Durango, Co Status: Offline Points: 736 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
I'm wondering when the ring gear becomes the weak link.....
I've been running 27 spline inner and outer shafts (with the big u-joints) with Warn Premium hubs and big wide 35" tires at rediculously low tire pressures downstream of a V6 with deep gearing. I haven't had any issues thus far, but it has always worried me. I try not to drive stupid, but I do a lot of pretty difficult trail riding. |
||
42 MB that had a one night stand with a much younger 69 CJ5 and a 50s GM truck.
|
||
oldtime
Member Joined: 12 Sep. 2009 Location: Missouri Status: Offline Points: 4140 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Metcalf, That's VERY impressive after seeing the massive tires you run.
I agree..... why increase the inner spline count if you don't increase the outer diameter. But then again I'm just another skinny tire guy. Ha Ha !
|
||
Currently building my final F-134 powered 3B .
T98-A Rock Crawler using exclusive factory parts and Approved Special Equipment from the Willys Motors era (1953-1963) Zero aftermarket parts |
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
The first stock shaft that I broke was the original shaft in my D30. To be fair, there was a pre warning noise coming from the u-joint but I didn’t know where the noise was coming from till eventually the u-joint broke on Chinaman Gulch. ... so, if I would have changed the u-joint when it started making noise, I would have been ok.
The second one I broke (the chromoly) one, was when I was in in my accident in Moab last year. I hit a lady head on in my truck. (Nobody was hurt). I was pulling trailer with BAM BAM on the trailer. The impact was so hard that BAM BAM broke free from his bindings and slid all the way to the front of the trailer. This impact caused the outer front axle shaft to shatter into 3 pieces. The third (stock) axle I broke was this year in Moab when we were on Green Day. My front tire sucked a large rock up into the fender. The rock wedges up in there and I guess somethings gotta give. I’d prefer not to break anything but when the stock shaft breaks, it is an easy fix and cheap. |
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
..... also, on the first shaft. That was when I first put a selectable locker in the front. At the time, I was new to lockers and didn’t have any experience using them, so when we did Chinaman, I just kinda turned it on, and left it on. Had I waited to turn it on when I truly needed it, and turned it off immediately after I no longer need it and before turning, I may not have blown the u-joint. Of course I know better now.
|
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
Metcalf
Member Sponsor Member Joined: 21 May 2009 Location: Durango, Co Status: Offline Points: 736 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
I also run a front automatic locker and a selectable rear locker open most of the time. My initial thought was that this was going to be harder on the front axle, but I haven't had any front axle issues. My thinking now is that generally it lets the front axle lock-unlock easier because it isn't being 'pushed' as much. My little flat fender has been very surprisingly capable machine for me.
|
||
42 MB that had a one night stand with a much younger 69 CJ5 and a 50s GM truck.
|
||
Rick G
Member Joined: 17 May 2015 Location: Amarillo, TX Status: Offline Points: 1467 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
So the breaking of the chromoly outer shaft (in the accident) makes sense to me now. I was having a difficult time imagining the circumstance where an outer axle shaft would shatter before twisting an inner shaft or breaking the ujoint and/or yoke under driven power. That makes me feel a little better about building a 30/27 setup. Metcalf’s experience has really thrown a wrench into the mix, however; especially considering Ward broke a D44 inner shaft and didn’t even know when it happened.
|
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Ward's shaft broke cleanly: ... I just didn't like the way my chromoly shaft splintered into pieces. Edited by jpet - 27 Apr. 2018 at 2:01pm |
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
Bridog
Member Joined: 04 Oct. 2016 Location: Holt, MO Status: Offline Points: 416 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
The only chromoly axle shaft I have broken was an outer shaft on the Dana 44 in the front of Blueberry. I broke it last fall and like Ward's experience in Moab, I did not know I broke it until later and I also continued to wheel on it for the rest of the day. It broke clean like the pic shows and did not damage the spindle. The shaft was about 8 years old and had been slightly twisted for the last couple years before ultimately breaking.
If I had to prioritize what I would like to see break first in a front axle (Dana 30 or Dana 44) it would be the lockout, outer shaft, inner shaft, and then the u-joint. Most of the time when I see a front u-joint fail it damages both the inner shaft and the outer shaft. So for the following reasons I like to protect that u-joint: (1) You absolutely cannot drive on a broken u-joint, you can drive on a axle shaft failure if it breaks clean. (2) If the “ears” of the axle shaft get bent out it can be very difficult to remove the shaft through the hole in the knuckle. (3) If the “ears” of the inner shaft get lined up with “ears” of the outer shaft like when the u-joint fails with the wheels turned the axial force of the shafts against each other can be high enough to separate a front axle at the ball joints. (4) Most aftermarket manufacturers warranty their axle shafts against breakage, but exclude damage to the “ears” due to u-joint failure. This means that a $25 u-joint just took out about $300 worth of axle shafts. If an inner axle shaft breaks in between the carrier and the inner axle seal (where they usually do) it can also be quite a chore getting the broken stub past the seal without having to remove the carrier. But if that is the case it is usually a clean break and can be driven back to camp to fix it. I think most would agree that the best and strongest front axle shafts are the RCV's. Constant velocity outer ends, super strong, and if any part of their shaft assembly breaks, it is replaced no questions asked. The next best option is what is in the front of Rojo and will probably be what ends up in the front of Elmo and that is the chromoly 27 spline inner, chromoly 27 spline outer, and the big Spicer 760X u-joint. The Spicer 760X is not greasable, but stronger than the previous Spicer 297X joint which was available in either greasable or non-greasable. This is the same as the Dana 44 u-joint and is what I am running in Blueberry with 37” tires. CTM makes an even stronger u-joint, but by the time you buy those along with choromoly shafts, you are getting pretty close to the RCVs. We have slightly bored out spindles on Dana 44 axles to accept larger outer shafts and I am not too concerned about it. It seems like a fairly common practice these days and is the only way some of the aftermarket shafts (including RCVs) can be used. I do carry an extra spindle in the truck for Blueberry if for some reason one becomes damaged, but I did that long before I had to bore the spindles out or was concerned about an axle shaft exploding inside the spindle. Everybody's experience with broken shafts on the trail is different and therefore their opinions are different and this is just mine. I carry limited tools on the trail, so my goal is usually not to fix it on the trail, but at camp. Brian |
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Brian, Who made your axle shafts? Mine are Alloy.
|
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
Bridog
Member Joined: 04 Oct. 2016 Location: Holt, MO Status: Offline Points: 416 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
The broken shaft was made by Superior Axle. I was told that they no longer make axle shafts for passenger vehicles. The replacement is a Ten Factory which is a division of a Motive Gear. Not sure about the inner shafts...I would have to dig through some old receipts.
|
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Well after some digging of my own, I think my Alloy shaft might have a 10 year warranty .... hmmm.
|
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
jpet
Moderator Group Sponsor Member x 5 Joined: 30 Apr. 2008 Location: Ramsey, IL Status: Offline Points: 11173 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Interesting that the Motive Gear version is much less expensive than Alloy:
Motive Gear Dana 30 Axles Alloy Dana 30 Axles |
||
CJ2A #29110 "General Willys"
MB #204827 "BAM BAM" "We do what we can, and we try what we can't" |
||
Metcalf
Member Sponsor Member Joined: 21 May 2009 Location: Durango, Co Status: Offline Points: 736 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
These are the axles that I am running on my D30
https://www.nitro-gear.com/Dana-30-4340-Chromoly-Nitro-Front-Axle-Kit-p/axn24106.htm |
||
42 MB that had a one night stand with a much younger 69 CJ5 and a 50s GM truck.
|
||
oldtime
Member Joined: 12 Sep. 2009 Location: Missouri Status: Offline Points: 4140 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Not sure what brand my chromoly shafts are ...
I bought them used ... not abused . Ha Ha !
Looks like maybe the Motive Gear brand on left ??? |
||
Currently building my final F-134 powered 3B .
T98-A Rock Crawler using exclusive factory parts and Approved Special Equipment from the Willys Motors era (1953-1963) Zero aftermarket parts |
||
Post Reply | Page <12 |
Tweet |
Forum Jump | Forum Permissions You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |